The discipline of a Chicago police officer who was investigated for alleged ties to a white nationalist group became a flashpoint during Friday’s wide-ranging police department budget hearing, which saw Superintendent David Brown on the defensive over discontent with his public safety plan, ballooning overtime costs and more.
Advertisement
Ald. Jason Ervin, 28th, questioned Brown on why Officer Robert Bakker received only a 120-day suspension over allegations including that he didn’t reveal he was interviewed by federal authorities about his alleged past involvement with the Proud Boys.
Advertisement
Brown defended the choice not to fire Bakker and said the investigation did not turn up sufficient evidence that the officer was affiliated with the organization.
“The Chicago Police Department has zero tolerance for any of its sworn members being members of hate groups or associated with hate groups,” Brown said in his first public remarks on the case. “The allegations put forth on this officer did not support by a preponderance of evidence, which is the legal standard, that this member associated with or was a member of a hate group — Proud Boys or any other hate group.”
Brown continued, “I will just say from a personal note, I’ve been Black a long time. I would not tolerate an officer being a member of or being associated with a hate group.”
A “preponderance of evidence” means the allegations being investigated must be more than 50% likely to be true. Brown said that was not the case with Bakker’s ties to the Proud Boys, but there were “minor violations” related to inconsistent statements from the officer to investigators about the extent of his interactions with members of the group.
“What we did prove is that this officer failed to notify us that he had talked with federal authorities and some other minor violations,” Brown said. “And because of those minor violations, we mediated a very high level of discipline. One-hundred-and-twenty days is a high level discipline for what we were able to prove.”
In April of this year, the department’s Bureau Internal Affairs resolved the case with a mediation agreement that said Bakker would not contest any of the allegations against him in exchange for the 120-day suspension. The city Inspector General Deborah Witzburg recommended that Brown reconsider that punishment but did not get a response.
On Friday, internal affairs Chief Yolanda Talley gave the surprising assertion that Bakker in fact was the one who requested the 120-day suspension in lieu of the department’s much-shorter expected offer.
“I’m just going to put it to you frankly,” Talley said, getting a nod from Brown to continue. “His suspension would not be more than five days for what we were able to prove. We brought him in for a second interview, and he just felt so bad that he was accused of this, he mediated 120 days. We didn’t offer him 120 days.”
Advertisement
Talley continued by pushing back on the idea of the Proud Boys being a hate group.
The Southern Poverty Law Center has designated the Proud Boys a hate group.
Bakker’s disciplinary case was first brought up when Ald. Byron Sigcho-Lopez, 25th, was the sole member of City Council to raise his hand in response to a colleague asking the chambers, “Can I get a show of hands of any aldermen in this room who would like to see less police?”
Fellow aldermen piped up, “I’ll take his,” in response. Sigcho-Lopez then left the City Council floor temporarily after shouting, “Take the white supremacists too. … It’s a shame to have white supremacists in the force.”
Advertisement
Also during Friday’s budget hearing, several aldermen pressed Brown on earlier comments he made blaming higher-than-budgeted overtime costs on special events such as next summer’s planned NASCAR takeover of Grant Park. Chicago police has $100 million budgeted for overtime this year but already spent $112 million so far on such costs, with more two months left in the year, Brown said.
“Primarily that’s a function of an increase — really an explosion of — special events across this city since Memorial Day weekend, much more than previous years, much more than pre-pandemic years,” Brown said, citing the Pride parade in June and the 2023 NASCAR street race. “As we add more and more special events that require security, we need to understand that’s additional overtime.”
Special events require organizers to find private security before they get the city’s approval, but that usually is not enough, and Chicago police staffing power is also required. But such events also require police signoff before taking place.
“You guys sign off on this stuff and you’re complaining,” outgoing Ald. Tom Tunney, 44th, noted.
Brown responded: “We’re not party poopers. We’re not going to say you can’t have the extra special events that we’ve had this past year, but it does require security. And so we’re responsible for making sure these events are safe.”
Advertisement
Another City Council member set to retire in 2023, 48th Ward Ald. Harry Osterman, expressed frustration with Brown repeating crime is down while fears of violence remain pervasive.
“I don’t feel that you have a comprehensive plan to address violence that has bought people in,” Osterman said. “Because of the lack of a cohesive plan, we’re an island. … But the violence spreads everywhere and without a cohesive plan with buy in from folks, we’re nowhere.”
Through this month, Chicago has seen double-digit percentage reductions in shootings and homicides — 20% and 18%, respectively — over last year. But since 2019, homicides and shootings in the city were each up by at least 30%, according to official Chicago police statistics.
