Former Alameda County District Attorney says it may take time, but ‘the truth will always catch up to the lie.’
In 2024, Mario Juarez, the U.S. government’s star witness in former Oakland Mayor Sheng Thao’s bribery case, steadfastly proclaimed his innocence of charges filed by the Alameda County District Attorney’s office under my leadership for allegedly passing tens of thousands of dollars in bad checks.
After he was charged in January 2024, Juarez fabricated a story claiming that I tried to extort $25,000 in cash from him for the anti-recall campaign.
In his recent courtroom testimony at Sheng’s trial, Juarez admitted that he knew the checks he wrote to print brokers Butterfly Direct Marketing were bad and would bounce. He also testified that he took money intended to pay the printer for himself. Juarez has a long, documented history of making false accusations and scamming business partners and acquaintances.
I denied Juarez’s allegation from the beginning. I never solicited a $25,000 payment from Juarez in exchange for dismissing criminal charges. It did not happen.
Now, in open court, the public is hearing Juarez admit that he knew the checks he wrote would bounce and that he took money intended to pay Butterfly for himself.
Juarez’ claims became a significant part of the political narrative surrounding the recall campaign that removed me from office. Even though I denied the allegations, for two years, Juarez’s allegations were repeated across news outlets and used as political ammunition against me. His former local criminal defense attorney, Ernest Castillo, proclaimed Juarez’ innocence and claimed that the charges were politically motivated. Castillo is now a judge in the Alameda County Superior Court.
Juarez’ false allegations against me had political consequences. The media and local bloggers were quick to amplify his allegations. Now they each have an obligation to give the public the same level of attention to the facts that have emerged in court. Anyone who repeated those allegations has a responsibility to revisit them now that Juarez admits he was guilty of the charges.
Juarez’s admissions also raise serious questions about why current District Attorney Ursula Jones Dickson chose to dismiss the charges against him rather than pursue accountability for the criminal conduct he has now admitted under oath. One of Jones Dickson’s first acts in February 2025 was to dismiss the charges against Juarez, despite the victim’s objections.
Political opponents should not be able to turn an unverified accusation into a public verdict. My reputation, my career, and the confidence of voters were all affected by an accusation that was never established as true.
The press should never confuse an allegation with proof and mislead the public about the veracity of a claim. And the current district attorney should not make prosecution decisions based on politics.
About Hon. Pamela Price
Pamela Price earned her B.A. from Yale College and a J.D. and M.A. from the Berkeley School of Law. She was admitted to practice law in California in 1983 and has specialized in federal civil rights litigation since 1991. She has successfully prosecuted civil and criminal cases in Bay area courts and is one of the few Black women to ever argue a case in the U.S. Supreme Court. She served as the elected District Attorney of Alameda County from 2023 to 2024.






