Per city policy, O’Malley had been randomly chosen to decide whether the officers should face a disciplinary hearing before the board after COPA and police Superintendent David Brown disagreed on how the case should proceed. COPA’s then-chief administrator, Sydney Roberts, who announced her resignation Wednesday, determined the officers handcuffed the boy for an “excessive amount of time” and recommended the officers each be given 30-day suspensions, according to police board paperwork. Brown, however, felt Spicuzza and Garduno should be exonerated but be required to attend training for “interacting positively with youth,” the paperwork stated.